How a boutique specialty 3PL went from nine leads in nine months to qualified brand meetings from the first weeks, with a six-figure brand closed inside month one.
A boutique, mid-market, FDA-registered 3PL serving CPG brands in supplements, beauty, food and beverage. A prior agency spent nearly a year and roughly ninety thousand dollars producing almost nothing. We rebuilt their client acquisition from scratch. Client details anonymized. Named version available on request.
A boutique, mid-market third-party logistics company built for the CPG brands most 3PLs get wrong: supplements, beauty, food and beverage, personal care. FDA-registered warehouses. Native integration with the ERP their largest target brands run. EDI for B2B and retail compliance. Service guarantees most operators their size don't offer.
Not a single-warehouse shop. Not an enterprise-scale operator either. The middle, where the operational sophistication is enterprise-grade but the client relationship is still founder-to-founder.
Their problem wasn't fulfillment. It was that nobody knew they existed.
Nine leads. Nine months. One close.
The client came to Romar AI in February 2026. They weren't cold-outbound skeptics. They'd tried it. For nearly a year they'd paid a generalist cold-email agency roughly ten thousand dollars a month to run brand outreach.
The result, in the client's own words:
We spent a ton of money and maybe got one customer out of it over the course of nine months. It was real bad. It was a lot of money spent.
Nine leads in nine months. One closed deal. Roughly ninety thousand dollars in agency fees.
One deal we closed — and, I want to tell you, maybe ten leads in nine months. Nine leads.
When we asked why he thought the engagement had failed, he didn't reach for the usual excuses. He named the actual problem:
I don't know if they had any experience in 3PLs.
That's the whole diagnosis in one line. A generalist agency running e-commerce playbooks against a 3PL audience will produce e-commerce results, which is to say almost nothing. Cold outreach into a 3PL prospect base needs vertical fluency: the specific pain of a beauty brand's Q4 kitting rush, the compliance vocabulary of a supplement operator, the way a food-and-beverage founder thinks about cold-chain risk. Without it, every email reads like it was written by someone who's never set foot in a warehouse.
We took the engagement in early March. We rebuilt the ideal customer profile from transcripts of their real sales calls, threw out every asset from the prior engagement, and spent three weeks warming fresh sending domains, with no shortcuts on deliverability. The first campaign went out on the first of April.
"Quite frankly, you're impressing me with the questions you're asking. The other agencies I've spoken to don't ask these kind of questions. They just ask 'what do you do, what's this, what's that.' They don't try to go into the details."
Three months in, the client started referring other companies to us, unprompted, on a client call.
Four changes. One system.
Vertical-specialist positioning
We stopped writing to "e-commerce brands" and started writing to supplement founders, beauty brand ops leaders, food and beverage COOs. Every angle referenced their vertical's specific pain: FDA cGMP, lot tracking, subscription cadence, temperature control, kitting complexity.
Founder-to-founder tone
Their CEO is a brand-builder, not a warehouse manager. The emails needed to sound like they came from someone who understood brand-building, not someone selling pallets. First-person, direct, no fluff.
ICP rebuilt from their own sales calls
We threw out the prior agency's lists and rebuilt the ideal customer profile from transcripts of their real sales conversations. Then we scored roughly 80,000 raw brand accounts against it. Only the fraction that actually fit made the list, including a segment nobody was writing to: established brands still doing their own fulfillment.
Reply handling owned end to end
We handled every positive reply in this engagement: qualified against the ICP, then booked directly onto their calendar. Before each meeting the client got a lead summary, the full email thread, and the prospect's account, and decided whether to take the call. No links in email one. No "just following up."
The deal that paid for the engagement, and the next twelve months.
Inside the first month of campaigns, one of the meetings we booked was with a supplements brand processing 6,000 to 10,000 orders a month, and still doing all of its own fulfillment. Shipping, storage, pick and pack, all in-house.
The client asked for their shipping data and came back with a full presentation: every pick-pack and warehousing fee on the table, and roughly one hundred and sixty thousand dollars a year in shipping savings on top, fees included.
We asked for their data. We're like, here's all our pick-pack fees, our warehousing fees — you're going to save 160 grand a year. And they're like, I cannot believe this. And they went and checked themselves and said: nope, you're right.
The brand ran the numbers themselves before signing. The deal closed inside month one and covered the entire engagement several times over on the first invoice alone.
Four patterns we're reusing right now.
The vertical filter matters more than the volume
A short list of brands that fit what the warehouse does beats a long list of every brand that ships. Every time.
The engine got smarter every month
Reply rates climbed across the engagement. Every booked meeting fed the targeting: which brand profile replied, which one showed up, which one closed. The profile behind the anchor deal, an established brand still self-fulfilling at real volume, became a segment of its own in the next campaigns.
The soft ask wins
Asking for a calendar slot in the first email is the worst-performing move in our data. A soft conversational close outperformed the direct availability ask by nearly two to one across our campaigns. We never ask for the meeting in email one.
Deliverability held the whole way
Three months of campaigns and no deliverability incidents. Three weeks of domain warmup before the first email, send caps respected on every inbox, and not one domain burned.
Qualified brand meetings from the first weeks of campaigns. A six-figure brand closed inside month one: a brand that checked the savings math themselves before signing. And a replicable playbook we now run across the Romar AI portfolio: for a US multi-warehouse operator, a Canadian 3PL specializing in DTC brands, and the client behind this case study.
The same playbook is currently running for a US multi-warehouse operator, a Canadian 3PL specializing in DTC brands, and the client behind this case study.
Named case studies available on request
See what outbound could look like
for your business.
Tell us who your offer fits. We’ll show you how many brands match, how we’d reach them and how the trial works. If we’re not the right fit, we’ll tell you.